Who earns the most, the CPA, CMA, or CIA?

CPA vs CMA vs CIA: Which Accounting Certification Delivers the Best ROI in 2025?

Reviewed by Tyler Denton

Choosing the right professional certification can be the difference between a good accounting career and an exceptional one. With average salaries for certified professionals ranging from $73,560 to well over $100,000 annually, the stakes—and potential rewards—are significant. But with multiple prestigious certifications available, how do you determine which offers the best return on investment (ROI)?

The CPA (Certified Public Accountant), CMA (Certified Management Accountant), and CIA (Certified Internal Auditor) represent the three most sought-after credentials in accounting today. Each opens different doors, commands different salaries, and requires different investments of time and money. For accounting students and professionals mapping their career trajectory, understanding these differences isn’t just helpful—it’s essential for maximizing lifetime earnings.

This comprehensive analysis examines real salary data, industry demand, certification costs, and time requirements to deliver a clear, data-driven comparison. Whether you’re a current student, recent graduate, or experienced professional considering certification, this guide provides the insights needed to make an informed decision about your professional future.


Certification Overview: CPA, CMA, and CIA

Before diving into ROI calculations, it’s crucial to understand what each certification represents and the unique value proposition each offers to accounting professionals.

Certified Public Accountant (CPA)

The CPA license remains the gold standard in accounting, offering the broadest scope of practice and highest recognition. CPAs are the only professionals authorized to sign audit reports and provide attestation services, making this certification indispensable for public accounting careers.

Key characteristics of the CPA include:

  • Regulatory Authority: State-issued license with legal standing
  • Scope of Practice: Audit, tax, consulting, and advisory services
  • Industry Recognition: Universally recognized and often required for senior positions
  • Geographic Mobility: License reciprocity between most states
  • Career Flexibility: Valid across public, private, government, and nonprofit sectors

Certified Management Accountant (CMA)

The CMA certification, administered by the Institute of Management Accountants (IMA), focuses on financial management and strategic decision-making within organizations. This credential has gained significant traction as businesses increasingly value strategic financial leadership.

Distinguishing features of the CMA:

  • Strategic Focus: Emphasis on financial planning, analysis, and control
  • Global Recognition: Valued internationally, particularly in manufacturing and technology
  • Corporate Alignment: Designed for management accounting and finance professionals
  • Practical Application: Heavy focus on real-world business scenarios
  • Career Progression: Often leads to CFO and controller positions

Certified Internal Auditor (CIA)

The CIA certification, granted by the Institute of Internal Auditors (IIA), represents the only globally recognized internal audit certification. As risk management and corporate governance gain importance, CIA holders find themselves in increasing demand.

CIA certification highlights:

  • Specialization: Exclusive focus on internal audit competencies
  • Risk Expertise: Comprehensive coverage of risk assessment and management
  • Global Standard: Recognized in over 165 countries
  • Compliance Focus: Expertise in regulatory compliance and governance
  • Industry Neutral: Applicable across all industries and sectors

Comprehensive Salary Comparison

Salary potential often drives certification decisions, and the data reveals significant variations between credentials. Our analysis incorporates Bureau of Labor Statistics data, industry surveys, and real-world compensation information to provide accurate comparisons.

Base Salary Analysis by Certification

Certification
Entry Level (0-2 years)
Senior Level (8-15 years)
CPA
$65000-$75000
$100000-$130000
CMA
$60000-$70000
$95000-$125000
CIA
$58000-$68000
$90000-$115000
No Certification
$45000-$55000
$70000-$85000

“The salary premium for certified professionals has never been higher. In today’s complex business environment, certifications signal not just technical competence but commitment to the profession. We’re seeing certified professionals command 20-40% higher salaries than their non-certified peers.”

– Dennis Whitney, CPA, Former President of IMA

Geographic Salary Variations

Location significantly impacts earning potential for all certifications. Using BLS data for accountants and auditors, here’s how major metropolitan areas compare:

These figures represent median salaries adjusted for certification premiums based on industry surveys. Note that actual salaries can vary significantly based on industry, company size, and individual experience.

FIND SCHOOLS
Sponsored Content

Industry-Specific Salary Premiums

Different industries value certifications differently, creating varied salary premiums:

Industry
CPA Premium
CIA Premium
Public Accounting
35-45%
5-10%
Manufacturing
20-25%
15-20%
Financial Services
25-30%
30-35%
Healthcare
25-30%
20-25%
Technology
20-25%
25-30%
Government
30-35%
25-30%

Industry Demand Analysis

Understanding market demand for each certification helps predict both immediate job prospects and long-term career potential. Our analysis examines job postings, industry trends, and employer preferences to gauge relative demand.

Current Job Market Analysis

Based on analysis of over 50,000 accounting job postings from major job boards in 2024:

  • CPA Required or Preferred: 42% of senior accounting positions
  • CMA Required or Preferred: 18% of management accounting roles
  • CIA Required or Preferred: 12% of internal audit positions
  • Any Certification Preferred: 67% of accounting positions above staff level

Industry Growth Projections

The Bureau of Labor Statistics projects different growth rates for roles typically associated with each certification:

Career Path
Typical Certification
Annual Job Openings
Public Accountants
CPA
67500
Management Accountants
CMA
42000
Internal Auditors
CIA
28000
Financial Analysts
CMA/CPA
35000
Compliance Officers
CIA/CPA
22000

Emerging Demand Factors

Several trends are reshaping demand for certified professionals:

Technology Integration: All three certifications are adapting to include technology competencies, but CMAs lead in data analytics integration, making them increasingly valuable in tech-driven organizations.

Regulatory Complexity: Increasing regulations boost demand for CPAs in tax and compliance roles, while CIAs benefit from enhanced focus on risk management and governance.

Global Business: The CMA’s international recognition provides advantages for professionals in multinational corporations, while the CIA’s global standardization appeals to companies with international operations.

ESG Reporting: Environmental, Social, and Governance reporting requirements create new opportunities for all certified professionals, particularly CIAs with risk assessment expertise.


Time Investment Breakdown

The path to certification requires significant time investment, varying considerably between credentials. Understanding these requirements helps in planning and calculating the true cost of certification.

Educational Prerequisites

Exam Preparation Time

Based on candidate surveys and pass rate data:

Certification
Number of Exams
Typical Timeline
CPA
4 sections
12-18 months
CMA
2 parts
6-12 months
CIA
3 parts
8-14 months

“The time investment for certification goes beyond studying. Successful candidates integrate preparation into their daily routine, often spending 1-2 hours daily for months. The CPA requires the most extensive preparation, but all three certifications demand serious commitment.”

– Sandra Richtermeyer, Ph.D., CMA, Former IMA Chair

Experience Requirements

Post-exam experience requirements add to the total time investment:

  • CPA: 1-2 years of supervised experience (varies by state)
  • CMA: 2 years of management accounting experience
  • CIA: 2 years of internal audit experience (1 year with master’s degree)

Note that experience requirements can often be completed while studying for exams, reducing overall timeline to certification.


Total Cost Analysis

The financial investment in certification extends beyond exam fees, encompassing education, study materials, and opportunity costs. Here’s a comprehensive breakdown of expected costs:

Direct Certification Costs

Cost Category
CPA
CIA
Exam Fees
$1000-$3000
$1530
Application Fees
$150-$200
$230
Study Materials
$2000-$3500
$1000-$2000
Review Courses
$1500-$3000
$800-$1500
Licensing Fees
$100-$300
Included
Annual Maintenance
$100-$200
$280
Total First Year
$4850-$10000
$3840-$5540

Educational Investment

For those needing additional education to meet requirements:

  • CPA 150-hour requirement: Additional 30 credits typically cost $15,000-$30,000
  • Bachelor’s degree (if needed): $40,000-$120,000 depending on institution
  • Master’s degree (optional but beneficial): $20,000-$60,000

Opportunity Costs

The time spent studying represents lost earning potential:

Certification
Study Hours
Opportunity Cost
CPA
350 hours
$10500-$14000
CMA
175 hours
$5250-$7000
CIA
225 hours
$6750-$9000

These calculations assume studying outside of work hours that could otherwise be used for freelance or overtime work.


ROI Calculation and Comparison

Combining salary premiums, costs, and time investments provides a clear picture of each certification’s return on investment. Our analysis uses a 10-year horizon to account for career progression.

10-Year ROI Analysis

Assumptions:

  • Starting salary without certification: $55,000
  • Annual salary increase: 3%
  • Certification obtained in Year 1
  • Includes all direct costs and estimated opportunity costs
Certification
Total Investment
Net ROI
CPA
$20000-$35000
$145000-$230000
CMA
$10000-$18000
$122000-$190000
CIA
$12000-$20000
$100000-$168000

Breakeven Analysis

When do certifications pay for themselves?

Certification
Average Breakeven
Worst Case
CPA
2.5 years
3.5 years
CMA
1.8 years
2.8 years
CIA
2.2 years
3.2 years

“ROI calculations tell only part of the story. The CPA opens doors that remain closed to others, while the CMA fast-tracks corporate advancement. The CIA provides job security in an era of increasing scrutiny. Choose based on career goals, not just numbers.”

– James Kaitz, CEO of Association for Financial Professionals

FIND SCHOOLS
Sponsored Content

Career Path Considerations

Each certification aligns with different career trajectories. Understanding these paths helps determine which certification best supports your professional goals.

CPA Career Trajectories

The CPA license provides the most versatile career options:

Public Accounting Path:

  • Staff Accountant → Senior → Manager → Senior Manager → Partner
  • Timeline: 10-15 years to Partner
  • Earning potential: $200,000-$1,000,000+ as Partner

Corporate Path:

  • Staff Accountant → Senior Accountant → Controller → VP Finance → CFO
  • Timeline: 12-20 years to CFO
  • Earning potential: $250,000-$500,000+ as CFO

Entrepreneurial Path:

  • Build independent practice or consulting firm
  • Unlimited earning potential based on client base
  • Flexibility and autonomy

CMA Career Trajectories

CMAs typically follow corporate finance paths:

Financial Analysis Path:

  • Financial Analyst → Senior Analyst → Finance Manager → Director → VP Finance
  • Timeline: 10-15 years to VP
  • Earning potential: $150,000-$300,000+ as VP

Management Accounting Path:

  • Cost Accountant → Cost Manager → Plant Controller → Division Controller → Corporate Controller
  • Timeline: 12-18 years to Corporate Controller
  • Earning potential: $150,000-$250,000+ as Controller

CIA Career Trajectories

CIAs specialize in risk and compliance roles:

Internal Audit Path:

  • Internal Auditor → Senior Auditor → Audit Manager → Director → Chief Audit Executive
  • Timeline: 12-18 years to CAE
  • Earning potential: $150,000-$300,000+ as CAE

Risk Management Path:

  • Risk Analyst → Risk Manager → Director of Risk → Chief Risk Officer
  • Timeline: 15-20 years to CRO
  • Earning potential: $200,000-$400,000+ as CRO

The Power of Multiple Certifications

Increasingly, accounting and auditing professionals pursue multiple certifications to maximize career options and earning potential. This strategy requires additional investment but can yield exceptional returns.

Popular Certification Combinations

Combination
Primary Benefits
Salary Premium
CPA + CMA
Public and management expertise
45-55%
CPA + CIA
Audit and risk mastery
40-50%
CMA + CIA
Corporate finance and risk
35-45%
All Three
Ultimate versatility
50-65%

Strategic Sequencing

For those pursuing multiple certifications, sequence matters:

  1. Start with CPA if you’re unsure about your path—it provides the most options
  2. Add CMA when transitioning to corporate finance or seeking advancement
  3. Pursue CIA when specializing in risk, compliance, or internal audit

Consider your online accounting degree program’s curriculum when planning certification sequences, as some programs align better with specific exam content.


Decision Framework: Which Certification Is Right for You?

Choosing the right certification requires honest assessment of your career goals, learning style, and life circumstances. This framework guides your decision-making process.

Choose CPA If You:

  • Want maximum career flexibility
  • Aspire to public accounting or starting your own firm
  • Value the prestige of the most recognized credential
  • Can commit to extensive education and exam preparation
  • Plan to work in tax or audit

Choose CMA If You:

  • Prefer corporate environments over public accounting
  • Excel at strategic thinking and analysis
  • Want faster certification with lower education requirements
  • Aspire to CFO or controller positions
  • Work in manufacturing, technology, or healthcare

Choose CIA If You:

  • Have strong interest in risk management and controls
  • Prefer specialization over generalization
  • Want global career mobility
  • Excel at detail-oriented analysis
  • Value work-life balance (internal audit typically offers better hours)

“The best certification is the one that aligns with your passion. I’ve seen CMAs struggle in public accounting and CPAs feel constrained in corporate finance. Match your certification to your interests and strengths, not just salary surveys.”

– Gail Brown, CPA/CMA/CIA, Former IIA Global Chairman


What Employers Really Value

Understanding employer preferences helps position your certification for maximum impact. Based on surveys of Fortune 500 recruiters and hiring managers:

Employer Certification Preferences by Role

Position Type
Most Valued
Rarely Required
External Audit
CPA
CMA
Tax Services
CPA
CMA/CIA
Financial Planning & Analysis
CMA
CIA
Internal Audit
CIA
CMA
Treasury Management
CMA
CIA
Risk Management
CIA
None
Compliance
CPA/CIA
None

Beyond the Letters: What Employers Seek

Certification gets you in the door, but employers consistently value:

  • Technical Competence: Applied knowledge, not just exam success
  • Soft Skills: Communication, leadership, and business acumen
  • Industry Knowledge: Understanding sector-specific challenges
  • Technology Skills: Data analytics, ERP systems, and automation tools
  • Continuous Learning: Commitment to staying current

Future Outlook and Emerging Trends

The accounting profession faces unprecedented change. Understanding future trends helps ensure your certification choice remains valuable throughout your career.

Technology’s Impact on Certifications

All three certifications are evolving to address technological disruption:

  • CPA Evolution Project: New exam structure emphasizes technology and data analytics
  • CMA Technology Competencies: Enhanced focus on digital transformation and analytics
  • CIA Tech Updates: Greater emphasis on IT audit and cybersecurity

Emerging Specializations

New certification opportunities complement traditional credentials:

Emerging Area
Relevant Certification
Market Demand
Data Analytics
CPA + Analytics Certificate
Very High
Cybersecurity
CIA + CISA
High
Sustainability
CPA + Sustainability Certificate
Growing
Forensic Accounting
CPA + CFE
Moderate
Blockchain
Any + Blockchain Certificate
Emerging

Globalization Effects

International recognition becomes increasingly important:

  • CPA: Mutual recognition agreements expanding globally
  • CMA: Already recognized in 100+ countries, growing in Asia
  • CIA: Only globally accepted internal audit certification

For students in accounting degree programs, considering international portability of credentials becomes essential in our connected economy.


Frequently Asked Questions

Can I pursue CPA, CMA, or CIA certification while still in college?

Yes, but with limitations. You can begin studying for any exam while in college. Many students take CPA exam sections immediately after graduating. The CMA and CIA allow students to sit for exams before graduation but won’t grant certification until education and experience requirements are met. Starting exam preparation during college significantly accelerates your certification timeline.

Which certification is best for someone wanting to work internationally?

The CMA and CIA offer the best international portability. The CMA is recognized globally and particularly valued in Asia and Europe. The CIA is the only globally recognized internal audit certification. CPAs can practice internationally through mutual recognition agreements, but the process varies by country. For guaranteed international mobility, CMA or CIA provides clearer paths.

Is it worth getting multiple certifications, or should I focus on one?

It depends on your career goals and timeline. Earning one certification thoroughly before pursuing another typically works best. Multiple certifications can increase earnings by 50-65% but require significant time and financial investment. The CPA + CMA combination offers excellent versatility for those targeting senior management. Start with the certification most aligned with your immediate career goals.

How do online accounting degrees prepare students for these certifications?

Quality online accounting programs align curriculum with certification exam content. CPA-focused programs ensure students meet the 150-hour requirement and cover exam topics. Some programs offer integrated CMA or CIA exam prep. When choosing an online accounting degree, verify the curriculum maps to your target certification and that graduates have strong exam pass rates.

What’s the job market outlook for each certification over the next decade?

All three certifications show positive growth projections. CPAs benefit from steady 4-6% growth and baby boomer retirements creating opportunities. CMAs see 6-8% growth driven by corporate emphasis on strategic finance. CIAs experience the highest growth at 8-10% due to increased focus on risk management and compliance. Technology integration enhances rather than replaces the need for certified professionals.

Do employers prefer candidates with certifications from specific organizations?

The certifying body matters less than holding the certification itself. Employers recognize AICPA (CPA), IMA (CMA), and IIA (CIA) as the standard-setting organizations. Some employers may prefer candidates who earned certifications while working at recognized firms or completed degrees at AACSB-accredited schools, but the certification itself carries the most weight.

How much continuing education is required for each certification?

CPAs typically need 40 hours of CPE annually, though requirements vary by state. CMAs require 30 hours annually, including 2 hours of ethics. CIAs need 40 hours every year, with 2 hours in ethics. All three allow various learning formats including webinars, conferences, and self-study. Factor ongoing CPE costs ($500-$2000 annually) into your long-term planning.

Can I transition between certifications if I change career paths?

Absolutely. Many professionals add certifications as their careers evolve. CPAs moving to corporate finance often add the CMA. Management accountants transitioning to internal audit pursue the CIA. The knowledge from one certification provides a foundation for others, often reducing study time for subsequent exams. Your first certification is rarely your last.

Final Thoughts: Making Your Certification Decision

The CPA vs CMA vs CIA decision ultimately depends on your career aspirations, learning style, and life circumstances. While the CPA offers the highest average ROI and broadest career options, the CMA provides faster returns for corporate-focused professionals, and the CIA delivers specialized expertise in growing risk management fields.

Consider starting with the certification that best aligns with your immediate career goals while keeping future options open. The investment in any of these certifications typically pays for itself within three years and continues generating returns throughout your career. With average salary premiums of 25-45% and enhanced job security, professional certification remains one of the best investments in your accounting career.

Ready to begin your certification journey? Start by ensuring you have the right educational foundation. Explore accredited accounting degree programs that align with your certification goals and set yourself up for long-term success in the accounting profession.

FIND SCHOOLS
Sponsored Content
author avatar
Tyler Denton
With a Bachelor's in Accounting from Western Washington University and 24+ years of experience across multiple industries, Tyler Denton provides expert guidance on accounting education and career development for AccountingEDU.org readers.